Magic Fountain Ice Cream
9825 Main Road, Mattituck, NY, 11952
One of Long Island’s most beloved ice cream parlors, Magic Fountain Ice Cream’s extensive menu has over 200 rotating flavors of homemade ice cream and soft-serve that cover the classics and then some. Though the decor is comfortingly old fashioned, the flavors can get adventurous with options like goat cheese, Guinness, coconut jalapeño, and local sweet corn.
It's not much to look at, but there's just something special about sitting out on a bench near your parked car, eating Magic Fountain. Since everyone else is sitting out there (they don't have inside seating) you can overhear everyone's conversations. Actually, I don't think anyone talks about anything but the ice cream and how good it is.
— Susan Connor of Susan Connor New York